Brace yourself for the onslaught of flavour. It strikes early, in a fist-clenchingly briny Tathra rock oyster, made even better by a brilliant sake-spiked Bull Kelp Martini. Then again soon after, in the mushroomy warmth of abalone dashi dramatically presented in a periwinkle shell. Unequalled sourcing and handling go without saying in Josh and Julie Niland’s kitchens, but lateral thinking sets them alight at Petermen. Lamb gets recast as yellowfin tuna in a genius take on Greece’s loukaniko sausage. Coal-grilled and butterflied red mullet feels right at home in a frothy curry with saltbush and astringent desert lime, every bit as vividly Australian as the Ken Done canvases on the walls. By the time the sure-footed service team brings it full circle – with baked-to-order cumquat madeleines in oyster shells – you’ll have little doubt this is Australia’s most seminal seafood restaurant. (At least, perhaps, until Saint Peter settles into its new Paddington digs.)
Petermen closed on 15 December 2024.
Josh Niland

Share this post